Showing posts with label Keystone XL. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Keystone XL. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 15, 2014

CANADIAN OIL SANDS PLAYERS NEED TO COME UP WITH A NEW UPGRADER AND JOIN HANDS WITH BC FIRST NATIONS CONSORTIUM

A First Nations-led consortium proposed on Monday 14 April to build an alternative project (to Enbridge’s Northern Gateway project) that would link Alberta’s oil sands to the British Columbia coast. Eagle Spirit Energy Holdings Ltd. and Vancouver-based Aquilini Group say they have signed non-disclosure agreements with a “substantial number” of First Nation groups in northern B.C., including some “staunchly opposed” to the Enbridge project.

The proposed one-million barrel-per-day pipeline has a tentative start date of 2020 and it is contingent on securing a “social license” from First Nations to operate. However, the Eagle Spirit project proposes to ship synthetic crude oil (SCO) (light crude) instead of bitumen, after being refined in an upgrading project. This business model is very much on the lines of a plan outlined in my blog of 27 January 2014 (CANADIAN PIPELINE PROJECTS IN LIMBO? NO WORRIES, HERE IS AN ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION!)

The above proposal is a win-win for all parties and makes a lot of sense in view of following:
·       It would be First Nations’ headache to secure the ‘social license’ and all the required approvals to build and operate the pipeline.
·       Transportation of SCO (light crude) in the pipelines will be more acceptable to local population (in BC) than bitumen.
·       An upgrader can be suitably located in either Alberta or Saskatchewan to be able to feed SCO for shipping overseas through West Coast and/or for pumping to refineries in Quebec, Ontario and New Brunswick.  
·       Building of an upgrader will squelch the criticism that by exporting bitumen to other countries many jobs (that could have been potentially created in Canada if there was an upgrader) would also export jobs overseas.
·       There will be less worry about Keystone XL’s outcome.

Now to the question of financing the projects:

Financing of the Pipeline: The Aquilini Group is reportedly willing to underwrite the cost of the pipeline as long as it gets support of all First Nations through whose territory the pipeline would travel. To some it may seem far-fetched or unrealistic, still, once the First Nations endorse the proposed project, financial analysts would get the chance to get down to the brass tacks regarding financing.

As a suggestion, why should Enbridge not like to collaborate on this proposal? They could possibly hedge their bets by investing in this project and carry on with their efforts on their Northern Gateway project despite number of First Nations bands informing NEB that they are not in favor of the project and the unbinding rejection of the project by the Kitimat city plebiscite.
  
Financing of the Upgrader: As suggested in my above cited blog dated 27 January 2014, the Provinces of Alberta and Saskatchewan and Mr. David Black (the BC billionaire who claims to have investors ready for investing in a refinery in Kitimat) could possibly share the cost of an Upgrader. Suncor and/or Total could revisit their economic models to fit in some investment sharing for this upgrader. Even TransCanada can think of diversifying and investing in this project depending upon the outcome of KXL project clearance by the US government.

Summary: All in all, the above pipeline project proposal predicated on an upgrader (in Alberta or Saskatchewan) seems to be a viable proposition and should be pursued by the various stakeholders and potential investors with great vigor and urgency. After all, the window of opportunity for oil and gas exports from Canada will not remain open for a long time. The Federal and Provincial governments should act as facilitators and help smoothen the path forward. Mind you, running with the above proposal does not mean that other viable proposals (e.g. Kinder Morgan pipeline twinning) cannot be pursued alongside. What may happen is that other projects may have to tweak some aspects, if and as necessary. 

Saturday, March 22, 2014

BALOONING DEFICIT, INABILITY TO FLEX MILITARY MUSCLE, FALLING RATINGS PUT OBAMA IN TIGHT SPOT – MAY SURPRISE PEOPLE WITH A DIFFERENT PERSONA

Let’s start with President Obama’s list of predicaments regarding international issues that is enabling his political detractors to portray him as a wimp:

De-nuclearization of Iran: United States is trying its best to avoid any option of use of force. Reason: With 17 trillion dollar deficit, US is virtually broke. It simply does not have money to spend on any military excursion – even the minor ones will add to the back breaking penury of US. Moreover, there is tremendous aversion in the American public toward another direct involvement. Furthermore, in case of Iran, any military option, which should be perhaps be a recourse of last resort, to be effective would need to be at a scale which would be prohibitively expensive for America and too heavy for war-weary American people’s will.

As a result, US is trying to tough talk its way to some face saving outcome with Iran. But, unfortunately, Iran apparently knows the monetary constraints of US to engage in any military action and would take advantage of the same anticipating correctly the trajectory of American diplomatic maneuverings of Kerry and the like.

However, a lot of American politicians from both sides of the isle are apprehensive of and uncomfortable with the approach US is adopting and do not seem to be very optimistic about a meaningful outcome. The Democrat front-runner of 2016 presidential election Hillary Clinton has said (as reported by NBC News website) “The odds of reaching that comprehensive agreement are not good,” Clinton said, per the Washington Post. “I am also personally skeptical that the Iranians would follow through and deliver. I have seen their behavior over the years…”.

Syrian crisis: US policy on Syria has been predicated on being hesitant to get directly involved, again, due to virtual financial bankruptcy of the US economy and war weariness of the American people. President Obama said Syria had “red line” when Assad regime used chemical weapons against the rebels. The world thought US would take some punitive actions through air strikes but at the last moment Obama went to the Congress to seek authorization for such an action which was turned down (by the Congress) as expected. There was huge disappointment with the ‘hawkish’ elements, like, Republican Senator John McCain and others. Obama looked timid, dithering and mousy.

The Assad regime seems to be reclaiming territories lost to the rebels. However, it is said that Obama administration’s reluctance toward any deeper involvement stems from presence of Muslim extremist elements fighting against Assad’s forces. It seems Obama administrations would prefer less extremist minded Assad prevail rather than Al-Qaida or Taliban type forces to win – this may not be a bad idea but unfortunately, for Obama, his detractors do not want to see that way.

Ukraine crisis: Russians have annexed Crimea and are now seem to be consolidating their position in the newly acquired region. The US and the European allies have imposed sanctions and articulated lot of tough sounding verbiage. However, all this does not seem to have caused any perceptible impact on Putin and his coterie. Obama detractors in the US are, again, criticizing him imputing Putin’s actions to his alleged ‘weak’ stance at the international stage.

It must be said that there was simply nothing that US or the Europeans could do in Crimea because of proximity between Russia and Crimea, and logistical challenges for the western powers to undertake any preventive action militarily. The only thing that may, however, be pointed out is that West was probably too lost in the euphoria and celebration of having caused the pro-Russian President of Ukraine and his cronies to flee, and failed to anticipate Russian reaction to it. The West remained oblivious of Russia’s sensitivities to developments in Ukraine which Russia considers as their backyard and also the century old historical linkages between the two.

US troops presence in Afghanistan beyond 2014: President Obama has yet to make a decision on the size of a post-2014 US force in Afghanistan after a 13-year war that has become highly unpopular among the American public. Outgoing President Karzai surprised the international community and many Afghans in December 2013 when he ignored the recommendation of an assembly of tribal leaders and other dignitaries to sign it, saying he would leave the final decision to his successor after 5 April elections.

A bipartisan delegation of US Senators to Afghanistan called on President Barack Obama this week to announce a decision on his plans for future troop levels in the country, on the assumption a much-delayed security pact eventually will eventually be signed with Kabul. One of the delegation members, Senator Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire, a Republican, said Obama should not wait for that to give an idea of what the US presence would look like after the Nato-led combat mission ends at the end of this year. This issue is confounding Obama and his reticence on the subject is providing ammunition to his opponents to criticize him for his indecisiveness.

Then there are some other issues that is causing headache to Obama:

Strains in relations with Israel: Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu is not very happy with the American policy trajectory on Iran and pressure on Israel to make some hard choices before 29th April toward resolution of Israel-Palestine imbroglio.

Since the global powers reached an interim agreement with Iran last November, Netanyahu’s warnings about Iran have been largely ignored. A frustrated Israeli leadership now appears to be ratcheting up the pressure on the international community to take a tough position in its negotiations with Iran. A front-page headline in the daily Haaretz this week reported that Netanyahu has ordered “to prep for strike on Iran in 2014” and has allocated US$2.87 billion for the groundwork. Earlier this week, Defence Minister Moshe Yaalon hinted that Israel would have to pursue a military strike on its own, with the U.S. having chosen the path of negotiations.

Whether Israel would translate its rhetoric in action remains to be seen and seems improbable, nevertheless the above mentioned developments were meant to jolt the global powers as a wake-up call.

Drop in approval ratings: Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll in March shows President Obama's job approval moved down to 41% in March from 43% in January, marking a new low. Some 54% disapproved of the job he is doing, matching a previous high from December, when the botched roll-out of his signature health law played prominently in the news. The latest survey also showed the lowest-ever approval in Journal/NBC polling for Mr. Obama's handling of foreign policy.

Democrats’ worry about losing Senate in November elections: As per NBC News, prominent figures still associated with President Obama and his White House team are sounding the alarm bell that the Democratic Party could lose the Senate -- if not more -- in November. Former White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs said that the Democrats’ control of the Senate was “definitely” in danger.

NBC News also reports that due to falling approval rating of Obama some vulnerable Democrats are already shunning Obama’s assistance. The president reportedly acknowledged his lackluster approval ratings during his meeting with Senate Democrats at a retreat recently.

The Democrat candidates Mark Begich in Alaska, Mark Pryor in Arkansas, Mary Landrieu in Louisiana, and Kay Hagan in North Carolina are especially keen on distancing themselves from Obama because of his overt opposition to Keystone XL pipeline project. The above mentioned four senators joined the Canadian Ambassador to US, labor union leaders and others in February this year to express support for this project. Obama has stated that he would give his decision by end of April. If he rejects this project, these four senators’ political future and Democrats’ hopes of retaining majority in Senate would be almost surely be compromised.

‘Weight’ of Nobel Peace Prize: President Obama seems to be continually weighed down by Nobel Peace Prize conferred on him – he seems to be struggling with himself on every issue that involves potential of military option; he seems to feel hand cuffed and suffer from dissonance within himself due to this prize (and unsaid expectation that came with it). As well, Obama seems to be very worried about the legacy he would leave behind and how history would judge him on various issues – be it US interventionism, or stand on environment, or bipartisanship at Capitol Hill and so on.

So, what might Obama do now? It is quite clear that President Obama needs to do something different to shake off the following perception:
·       Professorial, less of a man in command at helm
·       Speaks too much (from scripted speeches)
·       More words, less of actual action (esp. regarding international matters)
·       Afraid of re-calibrating his stance on issues (which explains his being fearful of environmental lobby)
·       Paralysis by over analysis
·       Unreliable, shifty, dithering, indecisive
·       Worried about legacy and Nobel Peace Prize expectation

In order to deal with the above mentioned perception issues and not get relegated to being a lame duck president for two years, Obama needs to change tack, take decisive stands (e.g., he should okay Keystone XL instead of being cowed down by some of his so-called donors). Hopefully, the Democrats would see an invigorated, crisp, concise, bold person who is not worried about how history will judge him. After all, two years is too long a period to remain in a semi-retired ineffectual state waiting for the term to be over. One is remembered in history not because one shied away from unpopular stands but because one overcame one’s shyness to take a right stand.